In Defense of Attachment Parenting & Working Moms

I was recently reminded of Erica Jong‘s recent piece on motherhood in which she called attachment parenting a “prison” for women. I was poking around the internet looking for blogs/articles/whatever about attachment parenting & working moms. I didn’t find much, but what I did find was, sadly, not very encouraging. There’s Erica Jong and others who dismiss attachment parenting as bad for mom & baby, there are others who think attachment parenting is only for the stay-at-home-mom set, and then there’s some not-so-practical advice (at least for us lawyer-types).

This is too bad, in my opinion. Recognizing, of course, that everyone approaches parenting differently (given, among other things, the fact that every child is different), I have to say that attachment parenting absolutely can work for working moms (and dads). There’s a lot of negative stuff out there, and I just want to encourage professional/working/student moms to not dismiss this approach out of hand because they think it would be impossible or horrible or I-don’t-know-what. I’ve been pretty gun-ho about it from day one & have learned that indeed you can wear a suit & still practice AP.

In that spirit, I’m going to blog in the coming weeks (months, depending on how this whole “studying-for-the-bar” thing goes!) about my own experiences with attachment parenting and my take on how this approach to parenting can actually be great for working moms. My intent is to discuss the challenges and benefits of this approach and to just generally demystify the idea of “attachment parenting.” And given that a lot of the criticism out there stems from a basic misunderstanding of the ideas behind attachment parenting (ahem… Ms. Jong…) I am going to start with the basics.

If you’re curious and just can’t wait to learn more, please check out the Attachment Parenting International link on my blogroll — It’ll take you to a section of their site dedicated to the issues working parents face.

I plan to post about each of the 8 principles of attachment parenting. These principles are laid out by Attachment Parenting International (or API). First, I like that API recognizes all sorts of family configurations and that working out of the home is a fact of life for many mothers. Some of their suggestions may seem daunting at first, but what isn’t daunting about motherhood?! And while I may not follow everything on the API website, I do buy into the argument that the 8 principles can lay the foundation to a strong parent-child relationship. And I appreciate that many of the 8 principles… Aw, heck, I better just list them before I jump in:

  1. Prepare for pregnancy, birth, and parenting
  2. Feed with love and respect
  3. Respond with sensitivity
  4. Use nurturing touch
  5. Ensure safe sleep, physically and emotionally
  6. Provide consistent and loving care
  7. Practice positive discipline
  8. Strive for balance in personal and family life

All told, I think these eight principles are rather sensible and do not create a “prison” for women. They provide a set of guidelines for approaching this wild business of parenting and don’t require you do x or perform action y. But I won’t lie, either, following some of these principles can be damned hard (especially the positive discipline and the ensuring emotionally safe sleep). Overall, though, if you think this approach might be for you, it can work — regardless of whether you’re in law school, studying for the bar, or working as a practicing lawyer. Hopefully, that it is do-able will come out in future posts.



Filed under Parenting

10 responses to “In Defense of Attachment Parenting & Working Moms

  1. Pingback: Choosing to Attachment Parent in Law School… No I’m not crazy! | Mom, JD

  2. It would be quite interesting to read about your experience with AP and work! I am a full-time working mom and love AP – just need to figure out how to combine the two:-)

    • I’m still figuring it out, Anastasia! Take a look at some of the AP principles posts. They’re all written from a working mama’s perspective & I’m working on the next post in the series. Also feel free to post or email specific questions & I’ll be happy to share my experiences if I can!

      Thanks for stopping by!

  3. Deb

    Thanks for your site. It’s great to know there are other working moms who AP. The ones I know are stay-at-home. Being a working mom is challenging period, but choosing to AP takes it up a notch. I wouldn’t do it any other way though.

    • Hi, Deb! I’m so glad you found my little blog. It’s great to know we’re not alone or (totally) crazy, isn’t it! That’s exactly why I started this blog. Welcome & I hope you’ll continue to add to the discussion with your thoughts & ideas!

  4. TW

    I am also a working mom (electrical engineer) that APs. It is nice to here there are more of us out there!

    • Thanks for stopping by & saying hello, TW! We are definitely out here, even if not in grand numbers, & it’s so nice to hear from others! I hope you’ll stick around & share some of your experiences, too.

  5. Samantha

    I cannot wait to hear more from your blog! Today was my first day back to work, and ive been practicing AP since my daughter was born. I absolutely love it but working is a lot harder! look forward to hearing your experience.

  6. Greetings! Very useful advice within this post!
    It is the little changes that produce the largest changes.
    Many thanks for sharing!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s